back to About Alternatives

back to Publications and Documents

Non-Toxic Mosquito Control
By CROW, Inc.

Around the world, the most effective mosquito control has been shown to be a combination of common-sense strategies. A paradigm shift is needed in Winnipeg. Winnipegers need to understand their role in helping the City reduce mosquito populations and restore nature's ecological balance. A combined approach including the aspects outlined below is needed.

Paradigm Shift (Public Education):

  • Blame/Responsibility shifting
    • rather than laying any blame or expecting City employees to take care of this problem for us, we all have to understand that we need to work together to reduce mosquito populations
    • mosquitoes don't usually fly very far--if you have mosquitoes in your back yard, they probably hatched there

  • Resource shifting
    • we must stop investing in poisons (which have been shown to increase mosquito populations over time) and start investing in projects that will restore natural predator populations and people's ability to protect themselves
    • obviously, over time, reduced exposures to toxins will result in reduced health care costs

  • Tolerance shifting
    • it is unreasonable and arrogant to assume we can eradicate a specie from the food chain without creating consequences
    • if we were not already sick or immune depleted because of toxic exposures, we would all stand to benefit from the WNv antibodies being bitten by an infected Culex tarsalis mosquito may provide
    • towns that have switched to non-toxic mosquito control measures have had to suffer through only one summer of high mosquito counts before Mother Nature restored equilibrium

Source Reduction: the best way to prevent mosquito breeding is to remove stagnant water

  • drainage
  • expand the TEEAM project into every area of Winnipeg: teams of students can clean yards, eaves troughs, etc (note. this means more than identifying needs, this means doing the work)
  • coordinate community clean-up days when volunteers could help the elderly or infirm remove breeding sites from their yards
  • continue advertising personal means to reduce breeding sources

Personal Protection

  • incentives are needed (subsidies, tax breaks) to build gazebos or screened porches, repair window screens, purchase kitchen tents, etc.
  • building codes could be updated to require screened-in areas in new buildings
  • incentives could be provided (subsidies/remove sales tax?) to purchase mosquito net clothing
  • continue to educate (wear long, loose, light clothing and non-toxic repellent, and avoid exposures from dusk to dawn)

Natural Predators: a healthy bird population is our best defence against West Nile virus

  • If the City were to stop applying toxins regularly, residents could be encouraged to support the return of natural predators, such as:
    • dragonflies and other flying insects (contact CROW Inc. for dragonfly pond instructions)
    • purple martins, bats and other birds (Did you know? Humans are not usually the mosquito's first choice for a blood meal. If more birds were around, fewer humans would be bitten.)
    • nematodes, frogs and larvae-eating fish

Natural Repellents

  • Many plants have repellent properties. Some work while planted in the ground, and others are processed and used in herbal repellents:
    • cedarwood, garlic, lemongrass, frankincense, cinnamon, basil, rosemary, cloves, peppermint, lemon balm, onions, feverfew, thyme
    • scented geraniums, marigold, tomato, eucalyptus
    • citrosa, lemon thyme, citronella grass, tansy
  • Rubbing freshly picked sage leaves on the skin and clothing also works

Larviciding

  • a sonar device is now available which is said to kill only mosquito larvae